Choosing between Montessori and daycare is a big decision, and it's important to understand the differences and similarities between the two. The schedules, noise levels, cleanliness, and type of education are all different depending on where you go to school.
Montessori vs. Daycare: What's the difference, what's the similarity, and how do you choose?
Early childhood education is a topic that many parents and guardians are interested in learning more about. No matter if you are looking to give your child a head start on their schooling or you require childcare while you are at work, you may have questions about the differences between Montessori and traditional daycare programs.
Despite the fact that these two facilities appear to be similar, they are vastly different. Here are a few things to think about before deciding which school to send your child to.
Montessori vs. Daycare – Similarities and Dissimilarities
At first glance, Montessori schools and day care facilities appear to be nearly identical. They are both designed for younger children and have lower teacher-to-student ratios than classrooms intended for older students, which is beneficial.
Both environments have toys that are appropriate for the age of the children, and children are left at the facility to be watched over by a teacher.
In addition to these similarities, there are a plethora of differences between them. Despite the fact that they may not be immediately noticeable, these inequalities are critical to consider when deciding on a program for your child or children.
There are some differences between Montessori and daycare.
Discovery at a Faster Pace
The Montessori method of teaching was developed around the turn of the twentieth century, and its origins can be traced back to the principle of allowing the child to direct their own education. Several hours are spent playing and engaging in supervised self-discovery. The environment is similar to that of a traditional day care center.
Even at a young age, children in a Montessori environment are encouraged to be themselves and to pursue their interests. Students can progress at their own pace of discovery, which, when you think about it, is a fairly natural process.
Take, for example, babies. Some babies begin walking at nine months, while others begin walking at 14 months. However, unless there is a medical issue, both the early and late walkers will be mobile at some point in their lives. A nine-month-old baby should not be held back until the 14-month-old baby has caught up.
The opposite is also true: prodding and forcing a 14-month-old to keep up with the earlier walkers could be detrimental to the baby's psychological well-being. Early and late learners alike can progress at their own pace in a Montessori environment, resulting in increased self-confidence and mastery of the subject matter.
In a daycare setting, there is a more one-size-fits-all approach to child development. Child care facilities divide children into groups based on their age – sometimes in six-month increments – or developmental stage – crawlers, walkers – which forces children to conform to a mold that may not be appropriate for them at the time.
Timetable for the day
When compared to Montessori schools, daycares follow a more rigid schedule. Children in a daycare setting move through activities in a logical sequence, doing specific things at specific times.
If they want to continue playing with a toy or were just about to figure out how to put the final piece into the floor puzzle, what happens? They won't have the opportunity to finish.
Montessori enables children to move between activities at their own pace, allowing them to spend more time on what interests them while also being able to move on quickly if they have mastered a concept or skill. Despite the fact that this setup appears to be appropriate only for grade school, babies are capable of engaging in play and transitioning from looking at books to stacking blocks or observing their surroundings.
In a Montessori environment, it is ideal to provide children with the time and space to exercise their independence.
Noise Levels and Environmental Cleanliness
Daycares are notoriously noisy, which can make it difficult for children to concentrate at times. Disorderly play also results in messes that must be cleaned up on a regular basis.
Because Montessori programs are concerned with the whole child and their thought processes, they tend to be quieter, cleaner, and more focused environments in which to foster the development of the child's mind and intellect.
Teacher Training and Student-to-Teacher Ratio
Unfortunately, many daycare centers pay low wages to their employees and provide only rudimentary training, resulting in a high turnover rate. This lack of continuity is not conducive to the development of young children.
It is the practice itself that is taught to Montessori teachers, which results in educators who are committed to the philosophy of child-led learning.
Teachers tend to be in the profession for a long period of time because it is a lifestyle rather than a job. The children benefit from consistency because they recognize a familiar face.
The fact that their child's educator is aware of that particular student's learning style, abilities, and interests is beneficial to the parents, as well as the child.
The same can be said for the administration of the Montessori environment, as they are also familiar with the methods and philosophies that will provide your child with a strong head start in their education.
Education with a definite purpose
When comparing Montessori to daycare, one of the most important factors to consider is intentionality. Children can begin formal learning at a young age, and in a Montessori environment, each activity, learning center, and toy serves a specific purpose in guiding the student towards higher levels of thinking and understanding.
In a daycare setting, children can engage in unsupervised free play. Yes, children can – and do – continue to learn through open play in a Montessori environment, but it is extremely deliberate and structured.
Relationships with other people
Focusing on the child as a whole is a distinguishing feature of the Montessori approach, and this includes the use of positive discipline. In a Montessori setting, rather than putting a child in time out or simply taking away a toy, as would be the case in a daycare setting, students learn about the behavior that is underlying what they are doing.
A student who hits another student with a block will be disciplined by the Montessori teacher, who will not only remove the block, but also talk to the child about why that action is wrong, how it could harm the other child, and how to deal with it in the future.
In addition, the teacher will make an effort to understand why the behavior occurred. Perhaps the child was frustrated, or perhaps another student made the decision to remove the block. Reasoning and critical thinking are introduced to children at a young age, which results in increased confidence and a better understanding of the consequences of their actions as a result.
Montessori vs. Daycare: Which Is Better for Your Child?
In contrast to some – but not all – daycares, Montessori environments are more purposeful and have an end goal in mind, while some daycares can be a glorified form of babysitting.
Childcare facilities are not all the same. In the same way that not all Montessori schools are the same, not all daycares are created equal.
When deciding between Montessori and daycare, the best thing to do is to visit the facilities in your neighborhood.
Inquire with the administration and the teachers about their educational philosophies and practices. Examine the classrooms to see what kinds of educational activities and toys are available to the students. Talk to other parents about their own parenting experiences.
If you are unsure about where to send your child, it is best to do your research and make an educated decision in order to ensure that your student has a positive experience.